Controversial Federal Council vote on the immigration law – how long ago was it?
The background
On March 22, 2002, Federal Council President Klaus Wowereit declared the immigration law to have been approved by the Federal Council. However, the immediate focus was on the question of whether valid consent had even been reached. Brandenburg's representatives initially voted contradictory. After being asked, Wowereit interpreted the state's votes as approval. This was crucial because the votes of a federal state in the Bundesrat can only be cast uniformly. Behind the procedural dispute was a fundamental political dispute: the law was intended to comprehensively reorganize immigration, the residence of foreign people and integration offers. This affected both the labor market and Germany's self-image as a country of immigration. The vote therefore did not bring a permanent legal conclusion. In December 2002, the Federal Constitutional Court ruled that the law had not received the necessary approval because of Brandenburg's invalid vote. Only after further negotiations was a revised regulation reached, which came into force in 2005. The March date marked a particularly visible conflict between reform policy and the binding rules of the federal legislative process.