“Soldiers are murderers”: Karlsruhe strengthens freedom of expression – how long ago was it?
The background
On October 10, 1995, the Federal Constitutional Court overturned several convictions for statements such as “soldiers are murderers.” The focus was on the question of when blanket criticism of the military offends individual soldiers. The judges asked that the wording and context be carefully interpreted and possible other interpretations taken into account. The decision was not a license for any insult. Rather, he emphasized the high priority of freedom of expression, especially when it comes to pointed contributions to public debates. A statement about soldiers in general could not simply be treated as an attack on the personal honor of certain members of the Bundeswehr. The decision became an important reference point in the German dispute over where harsh political criticism ends and criminal insults begin.