Skip to content
Back to the 2010 chronicle
Politics

Constitutional Court demands comprehensible Hartz IV standard rates – how long ago was it?

09. February 2010
16 years, 9 months and 7 days ago

The background

On February 9, 2010, the Federal Constitutional Court declared the calculation of the Hartz IV standard rates at that time to be incompatible with the Basic Law. The judges did not directly criticize the amount of the benefits, but rather their insufficiently comprehensible derivation. Children's needs in particular had to be determined independently instead of being derived across the board from adult sentences. The ruling strengthened the fundamental right to a humane minimum subsistence level. In addition to food, clothing and accommodation, this also includes opportunities for social participation. The legislature had to create new rules by the end of 2010; The previous benefits were initially continued to be paid. The decision was groundbreaking for German social policy because state livelihood security must be transparently justified and children must not be treated simply as reduced adults.