Skip to content
Back to the 2002 chronicle
Politics

Federal Constitutional Court stops the immigration law – how long ago was it?

18. December 2002
23 years, 10 months and 29 days ago

The background

On December 18, 2002, the Federal Constitutional Court declared the immigration law invalid due to an error in the approval of the Bundesrat. The focus is on Brandenburg's inconsistent voting: Prime Minister Manfred Stolpe and Interior Minister Jörg Schönbohm represented different positions in the vote. Nevertheless, the country's votes were seen as approval. The Basic Law requires that a federal state cast its votes in the Bundesrat uniformly. According to the court's decision, the required consent to the law was not available. The decisive factor is the parliamentary procedure, not a comprehensive constitutional assessment of the planned immigration rules. The red-green federal government wanted to use the law to reorganize, among other things, labor migration, humanitarian immigration and integration. The ruling prevents the planned entry into force at the beginning of 2003 and forces politicians to carry out new negotiations. The case shows how strongly federal legislation depends on the majority and the binding voting rules in the state chamber.